Gathering, crafting, and progression design

Several comments about Scars of Honor focus on day-to-day progression systems, especially gathering, crafting, item value, and the pace at which players gain convenience.

The overall direction favors meaningful upgrades, active participation in professions, and progression that remains understandable to new players while still offering depth for long-term mastery.

Gathering minigames

Gathering in Scars of Honor is described as more active than a simple click-and-wait interaction. Resource collection is said to involve minigames, with the player needing to complete the interaction properly in order to finish the task.

This is presented as an intentional improvement over passive gathering loops, making the player an active participant rather than a spectator.

Crafting and profession value

Professions are treated as important to character survival and progression. Mining and blacksmithing are discussed in particular, alongside cooking and first aid as examples of support-oriented progression that can materially affect performance.

The broader implication for Scars of Honor is that professions should matter in practical play rather than existing as low-impact side systems.

Item rarity and upgrade impact

A strong preference is expressed for gear that feels rare and meaningful. The desired model is one in which a single item drop can noticeably change combat performance and create a memorable sense of progression.

This philosophy is contrasted with systems where upgrades are frequent and low-impact. The preferred Scars of Honor direction is for gear to retain emotional and mechanical value, so that obtaining an item feels consequential rather than routine.

Simplicity and depth

An explicit design goal is that the game should be easy to understand but difficult to master. Casual players should be able to grasp the basics quickly, while dedicated players should still find enough mechanical depth to spend long periods improving and optimizing.

This principle is framed as central to the long-term health of Scars of Honor: accessibility at the surface level, with deeper systems underneath for mastery.

Early mounts and travel convenience

Mount timing is discussed as an open design question. Delayed access can make mounts feel rewarding, but long stretches of early travel are also described as frustrating and potentially off-putting.

The preference expressed here leans toward giving players access to mounts earlier, so they can explore more of the world without excessive downtime. The trade-off between convenience and milestone value is acknowledged, but the emphasis is on keeping movement engaging rather than burdensome.

Source

• Recording: 🔴 MMoRPG Dev 🔴Plays WoW Hardcore with the community! NO SPOILERS!
• YouTube: Watch on YouTube
• Published: Sunday, November 16, 2025 at 9:12 PM UTC